LaoLong AI Trading Bot, 3Commas and Pionex solve different problems. LaoLong trades for you on Hyperliquid. 3Commas is software for running your own bots on your exchange accounts. Pionex is an exchange with free built-in bots that you configure yourself. Pick LaoLong if you want hands-off long and short trading from $10. Pick 3Commas if you want to build strategies across many exchanges. Pick Pionex if you want free grid bots and are happy to keep your funds on its exchange.
This comparison is published by LaoLong, the team behind LaoLong AI Trading Bot. Facts about 3Commas and Pionex come from their own pages and named reviews, checked on 30 October 2026, and are linked below.
Side-by-side (as of 30 October 2026)
| LaoLong AI Trading Bot | 3Commas | Pionex | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Type | Done-for-you trading bot | Bot software for your exchange accounts | Exchange with built-in bots |
| Who sets the strategy | The bot: rules-based trend engine plus an AI risk officer | You (DCA, grid, signal bots) | You (16 built-in bots) |
| Markets | Perpetual futures on Hyperliquid | 9 exchanges listed; spot, and futures on Pro and Expert | Pionex spot and futures |
| Long and short | Yes | Yes, with a futures plan | Yes, futures grid: long, short or neutral |
| Who holds the money | One shared Hyperliquid account; your balance is your share | Your exchange account, via API key | The Pionex exchange |
| Price of the product | No subscription, order fee or profit share (October 2026) | $15, $38 or $105 a month (listed discount from $20, $50, $140) | Bots free |
| Trading fees | Hyperliquid fees and funding, included in results | Your exchange's fees | 0.05% spot; 0.02% maker, 0.05% taker on futures (per Coin Bureau) |
| Minimum | $10 | Set by your exchange | Not stated |
| Setup | Sign in with Telegram, deposit | Exchange account, API key, bot settings | Pionex account, bot settings |
| Public track record | Every closed AI trade call since July 2026, losses included | Depends on your settings | Depends on your settings |
| Risk layer | AI risk officer (Normal, Caution, Defense) on top of stops | Stops and take-profits you set per bot | Ranges and stops you set per bot |
Sources: 3Commas pricing, Coin Bureau's Pionex review, Pionex blog on fees. LaoLong figures come from our results and methodology pages.
How each one trades
LaoLong AI Trading Bot. A rules-based trading engine follows trends on liquid coins, long and short, on Hyperliquid perpetual futures. An AI risk officer reads the market and the news around the clock and moves the account between Normal, Caution and Defense. It can filter new entries, hedge with BTC and close a trade that became dangerous before its stop. You don't pick coins, ranges or leverage.
3Commas. You build bots: DCA bots that average into a position, grid bots that trade a price range, and signal bots that act on TradingView alerts or other signals. 3Commas sends the orders to your exchange through an API key and describes itself as providing "software only" (3Commas pricing). The strategy, and therefore the result, is yours.
Pionex. You pick one of the built-in bots, such as spot grid, futures grid (long, short or neutral), DCA or rebalancing, and set its range and size. The bot runs on your Pionex exchange account, so there are no API keys involved (Coin Bureau review).
Costs on a $500 account
Fees matter most on small accounts. Here is what each product's own pricing means for $500, before market results:
- LaoLong: $0 a month to LaoLong as of October 2026. Hyperliquid's base fees are 0.045% taker and 0.015% maker (Hyperliquid docs). They are paid by the trading account and already included in every result we report, together with funding.
- 3Commas: $15 a month on Starter (spot only), which is 3% of $500 every month. Futures need Pro at $38 a month, or 7.6% of $500 a month. Exchange fees come on top.
- Pionex: $0 for bots. Trading fees apply to every fill: at 0.05%, each $1,000 traded costs $0.50. A grid bot that turns over its balance many times a month pays that again on every fill.
A subscription is a fixed cost, so it weighs less on a larger account. A fee per fill grows with how actively the bot trades.
Who holds your money
| Where the money sits | What protects it | What you must watch | |
|---|---|---|---|
| LaoLong | One shared Hyperliquid account; your balance is your share | The trading key can't withdraw; keys are kept in an isolated, encrypted signing service; withdrawals only to allow-listed addresses under an hourly cap | You rely on our controls. As of October 2026, our team reviews each withdrawal before payout, and money in open trades unlocks when they close |
| 3Commas | Your own exchange account | The API key's permissions, set by you | Never enable withdrawal on the key. In December 2022, 3Commas confirmed that leaked user API keys were genuine (Cointelegraph) |
| Pionex | The Pionex exchange | The exchange's own security; Coin Bureau cites proof-of-reserves audits | Exchange risk is your risk |
Track record
- LaoLong publishes every closed AI trade call, losing ones included: 214 calls have closed in profit, and the win rate of the public calls is 78.1%, as of 17 Nov 2026, 15:34 UTC. Each public call links to its original post. These are price moves without leverage. The methodology page defines every number.
- 3Commas and Pionex are tools, so results depend on the bots and settings each user picks. There is no single record to check, and a backtest is not a track record.
Pros and cons
LaoLong AI Trading Bot
- Pros: nothing to configure; long and short on perpetual futures; a concrete AI risk officer; $10 minimum; no subscription or profit share as of October 2026; every closed AI trade call published.
- Cons: a newer product (AI trade calls since July 2026, real-money trading since October 2026); a shared account instead of your own exchange account; withdrawals reviewed before payout; one exchange; leverage risk; Telegram needed to sign in.
3Commas
- Pros: mature platform; many exchanges and bot types; futures on higher plans; a demo account on every plan; money stays on your exchange account.
- Cons: subscription cost; you design and maintain every strategy; you must manage API key security.
Pionex
- Pros: free built-in bots; no API keys; futures grid in both directions; low listed trading fees.
- Cons: funds held by the exchange; you still choose every setting; per-fill fees add up on active grids.
Which should you choose?
- You want the bot to do the trading: LaoLong AI Trading Bot.
- You want to design DCA, grid or signal strategies on exchanges where you already have accounts: 3Commas.
- You want free grid bots and don't mind keeping funds on one exchange: Pionex.
For a wider list that also covers Bitsgap, Cryptohopper and Hyperliquid's HLP vault, see the best AI crypto trading bots in 2026. Before you deposit anywhere, run through our checklist for choosing a trading bot. Whichever you pick, trading carries risk: trades can close at a loss, and the CFTC warns that "AI technology can't predict the future or sudden market changes" (CFTC advisory).
How we compared
We compared the three products on what each one does, who holds the money, what it costs on a small account, whether it can trade long and short, whether its record can be checked, and how much setup it needs. We did not run 3Commas or Pionex bots with live money, because their results depend on the settings each user chooses. Prices and features are as listed by each company on 30 October 2026 and can change. Check their pages before you sign up.
Questions and answers
What is the difference between LaoLong, 3Commas and Pionex?
LaoLong AI Trading Bot trades for you: you deposit from $10 and a trading engine with an AI risk officer trades Hyperliquid perpetual futures, long and short. 3Commas is software for running your own bots on your exchange accounts through API keys. Pionex is an exchange with free built-in bots that you set up yourself.
Which is cheapest for a small account?
As of October 2026, LaoLong charges no subscription, order fee or profit share, and Pionex charges no fee for its bots; both leave only trading fees and, on futures, funding. 3Commas lists plans from $15 a month for spot and $38 a month with futures, which is 3% to 7.6% of a $500 account every month before exchange fees.
Which one keeps my money safest?
Each has a different model. With 3Commas, the money stays on your own exchange account, so the key must never allow withdrawals. With Pionex, the exchange holds your funds. With LaoLong, deposits go to one shared Hyperliquid account whose trading key cannot withdraw, and withdrawals go only to allow-listed addresses. None of these is risk-free.
Does any of them show a public track record?
3Commas and Pionex results depend on the settings each user picks, so there is no single record to check. LaoLong publishes every closed AI trade call since July 2026, losing ones included: these are price moves without leverage.